Justice Minister, UN official in heated argument
Justice Minister Dr. Wijeyadasa Rajapakse, PC, had a heated argument with visiting UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights and Counter Terrorism Ben Emmerson, QC, over UN intervention here as regards promotion and protection of human rights.
Sri Lanka in December 2015 extended a standing invitation to the UN Special Procedures Mandate Holders.
Emmerson began a five-day official visit here on July 10 to gather first-hand information about what the UN described as post-war initiatives in the area of counter-terrorism and assess how they affect the people.
Minister Rajapaksa strongly questioned the UN official resulting in an unprecedented fiery argument early this week, well informed sources said, adding that the meeting took place at the Justice Ministry.
Sources said Emmerson had been somewhat taken aback by Dr. Rajapakse’s outburst though the UN knew of his opposition to UN intervention here. Emmerson warned Minister Rajapakse that he would publicly announce the latter’s refusal to cooperate with the UN. The minister said that he was free to call media briefings.
Emmerson will discuss the situation at a media briefing at UN building at 202 Bauddhaloka Mawatha, Colombo 7 today at 3.00 pm. Sources said that reference would certainly be made to recent ‘clash’ with the Justice Minister.
Sources said that Minister Rajapakse had called the UN stand here unfair and unacceptable. Emmerson reported the incident to the UN.
A senior Foreign Ministry official yesterday confirmed the incident at the Justice Ministry.
A UN statement issued from Geneva before Emmerson’s arrival here quoted top British lawyer as having said, “I will seek to provide assistance in the discussion of the country’s counter-terrorism policy and legal framework as well as in the preparation and drafting of relevant legislative acts, with a view to ensuring that measures taken by the Government are in compliance with international human rights law.”
Minister Rajapakse recently called for reviewing Sri Lanka’s decision to repeal the Prevention of Terrorism Act (PTA) in the wake of those who had been demanding abolition of the legislation having to adopt draconian measures to counter terrorism. Sri Lanka has repeatedly assured the international community that the PTA would be repealed to pave the way for Anti-Terrorism Law conforming to international norms.
Emmerson also had high-level meetings with representatives of the Government, including the ministries responsible for foreign affairs, law and order, Southern development, justice, defence, finance, media, prison reforms, rehabilitation, resettlement and Hindu religious affairs.
The Special Rapporteur met law enforcement officials, members of parliament, members of specialised police departments, the National Police Commission and the Human Rights Commission.
Emmerson interviewed persons suspected or convicted of terrorist crimes now in detention.
Emmerson was the former senior counsel for the Independent Inquiry into child abuse headed by Prof. Alexis Jay. Emmerson quit the Independent Inquiry late last year following an allegation of sexual assault in a lift against him. However, Emmerson was fully cleared by his law chambers, Matrix following an independent inquiry into the allegations of sexual assault and sexual harassment.
Sources said that Emmerson had also met representatives of the international community, lawyers, academics, and representatives of non-governmental organisations.
The Special Rapporteur will present a comprehensive report with his findings and recommendations to the UN Human Rights Council in March 2018.
Government sources said that the recent flare-up took place in the wake of Minister Rajapakse rejecting controversial report prepared by Ms. Mónica Pinto, the former Special Rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers following her visit to Sri Lanka and presented to Geneva Council by her successor, Diego García-Sayán. The report reiterated call for foreign judges and other experts in accountability mechanisms set up in accordance with Geneva Resolution co-sponsored by Sri Lanka in Oct 2015.
In addition to Pinto, the Working Group on Enforced and Involuntary Disappearances, the Special Rapporteur on Minority Issues, the Special Rapporteur on Torture, and the SR on the promotion of truth, justice, reparations and guarantees of non-recurrence visited Sri Lanka.
The Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of the Right to Freedom of Opinion and Expression, the Special Rapporteur on the promotion of truth, justice, reparation and guarantees of non-recurrence, and the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention are expected to visit Sri Lanka.
(Source: The Island – By Shamindra Ferdinando)
Latest Headlines in Sri Lanka
- 32 Sri Lankans rescued from human trafficking in Myanmar November 26, 2024
- PUCSL warns CEB: Submit tariff plan by December 6, 2024 or face action November 25, 2024
- ADB approves $200 million to modernize Sri Lanka’s power sector November 25, 2024
- Over 120,000 tourists arrive in Sri Lanka in first 20 days of November 2024 November 25, 2024
- Court orders release of Sujeewa Senasinghe’s SUV on Rs. 100 million bond November 25, 2024
visiting UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights . Kick the bastered out of the country.
This is the consequence of Geneva Resolution co-sponsored by Sri Lanka in Oct 2015. Subsequently, SL has become punching bag (or even a football) for UN officials to showcase human right violations and rule of law. They will come at their will produce reports pinch SL hard as they can. If our legal system and our judges are not good send them home and import judges and lawyers from South Africa, Zimbabwe, Fuji, Haiti, Ruwanda, Iraq, Syria, Egypt, Israel, Libya, etc.
I am sure UN has better things to engage as opposed to experimenting with half baked policies dictated by the UN to be enacted into law in Sri Lanka. What Ben Emerson ought to be looking at is what our constitution has to say about human rights and premises associated with it and Sri Lankan Constitutional read into it and resolve any contradictions. Considering that the original Sri Lankan constito defend human rights tution was crafted by the British and clauses in connection with minority rights and hum an rights for British under colonial rule with its vast experience in Africa, South Asia and South East Asia must have been familiar with what is involved and and that there is no universal formula. The events taking place in the middle east are in violation of human rights that the UN has not accounted.
Sri lanka houses probably the largest UN offices in South Asia and one begins to wonder as to what they do to be there.
These buggers who don’t have anything better to do come here and dictate to us because we welcome these basterds with open arms. We are the only country invite these drop out rip rap because there have a skin colour of a deteriorated corps. You call them white Europeans. . Other countries don’t care shit about these stupid wankers.
Hey Ranjith, Amarakoon and Zama,
There are many kinds of people in this world, some white, some black, some brown and some yellow.
To survive and grow, we should learn to live with all of them including tolerance of all their behaviours.
In this case, rather than berating this uncultured suddha, I will take up my case with the stupid brown leaders of our nation who signed off and supported the UN Resolution not only for one year but for many years.
These leaders who sign off stupid resolutions are the ones to blame, not the stupid suddha.
I have been to so many countries and so far never found a white color person. Co lour of a deteriorated corps, Yes.
kneeranjala kheerthi නීරංජළා කීර්ති it is the class that matters but the class. in nuclear families as you are aware there a conflicts that go for generations and some escalates even to murder. how do you xplain this behaviour. the people who represent the people are what are described as pukka sahibs culturally they are nothing more than parayas. If historical facts sounds like berating then you ought to reflect on what berating is about
Dear Kneranjala Keerthi,
Well, to a certain extend I agree with your colour clarification. I lived/living and working with who are having other colours. I know their attitude and their behaviour (though I avoid generalization). Crux of the matter is, Sri Lank blindly (or knowing it) co-sponsored the Geneva resolution. Sri Lankans have a meek attitude towards foreigners (especially towards Westerners). We need diplomats such as Danapala, Kadiragamar or even Nanda Godage. These people can rub-shoulders with any foreign rep. They are well educated and deserved be diplomats. There is another side that is Sri Lanka was/is governed by Colombo educated elites. Some call them Kalu Suda’s. These kalu suda’s always respect their elder brother real sudda. People such as Ben Emmerson knows that and always try to bully us. Former US VP Kerry, US Samantha Power, Cameron, (even Price Husain, Nawaneethan) all this this isn’t it?